Automatic transcription of piano music - Benchmark using Hybrid Decay/Sustain evaluation metric

Musical Pieces Albeniz :Suite espagnole Cataluna Heinrich Lichner: Fantasie über "Stille Nacht, heilige Nacht" M:P: Heller: Christfreuden Buegmueller: Etueden Op. 109 - Die Quelle Chopin: Prelude No.13 in F# Major, Op. 28 Chopin: Prelude No.14 in Eb Minor, Op. 28 Haydn: Piano sonata in G major, Hoboken XVI:40, 1. Movement Schumann: Scenes from Childhood Op. 15
Original audio
Vincent'10 FS=58, DS=52

SS=65
FS=56, DS=50

SS=62
FS=61, DS=50

SS=71
FS=62, DS=49

SS=75
FS=57, DS=61

SS=54
FS=51, DS=38

SS=63
FS=71, DS=62

SS=80
FS=74, DS=81

SS=66
Emiyia'08 FS=51, DS=56

SS=45
FS=36, DS=44

SS=28
FS=65, DS=65

SS=64
FS=65, DS=64

SS=65
FS=53, DS=67

SS=38
FS=29, DS=34

SS=25
FS=77, DS=81

SS=73
FS=63, DS=73

SS=52
Vincent B '07 FS=42, DS=43

SS=42
FS=32, DS=38

SS=26
FS=44, DS=42

SS=46
FS=53, DS=47

SS=59
FS=40, DS=40

SS=39
FS=38, DS=39

SS=38
FS=56, DS=50

SS=62
FS=62, DS=68

SS=56
Vincent H '07 FS=53, DS=49

SS=57
FS=40, DS=41

SS=39
FS=45, DS=42

SS=48
FS=69, DS=63

SS=75
FS=44, DS=40

SS=49
FS=47, DS=44

SS=50
FS=62, DS=55

SS=70
FS=76, DS=80

SS=72
Bertin'07 FS=32, DS=33

SS=30
FS=27, DS=29

SS=25
FS=36, DS=40

SS=32
FS=31, DS=31

SS=30
FS=21, DS=22

SS=20
FS=14, DS=14

SS=14
FS=31, DS=33

SS=29
FS=28, DS=34

SS=22
Ryyannen'05 FS=58, DS=50

SS=65
FS=46, DS=44

SS=48
FS=63, DS=59

SS=67
FS=62, DS=60

SS=65
FS=53, DS=61

SS=45
FS=41, DS=43

SS=39
FS=65, DS=56

SS=73
FS=72, DS=83

SS=62
Marolt'04 FS=55, DS=64

SS=46
FS=39, DS=46

SS=31
FS=59, DS=65

SS=53
FS=59, DS=57

SS=60
FS=56, DS=65

SS=48
FS=53, DS=54

SS=53
FS=79, DS=85

SS=72
FS=63, DS=73

SS=54
Genetic Algorithm FS=65, DS=69

SS=61
FS=46, DS=47

SS=46
FS=63, DS=65

SS=60
FS=51, DS=48

SS=55
FS=58, DS=69

SS=46
FS=59, DS=58

SS=60
FS=81, DS=82

SS=80
FS=80, DS=84

SS=76

Legend: FS=Final Score, DS=Decay Score, SS=Sustain Score. All rates are in %. Click on the to see the respective generated music score: the empty rectangles represent the ground-truth notes,and the filled rectangles correspond to the transcriptions.

This is an extended benchmark from Valentin Emiya benckmark including 3 new algorithms: Vincent'10, Ryyannen'05 and the proposed Genetic Algorithm.